⚖️ Hiring
Employee vs Contractor
Calculator
The contractor appears cheaper — until you run the real numbers. See the true total cost comparison before you decide how to hire.
👤 Employee Additional Costs (Annual)
🔧 Contractor Additional Costs (Annual)
More Cost-Effective Choice
Loading...
By $0 per year
True Employee Cost
$0
All-in annual cost
True Contractor Cost
$0
Rate + overhead + fees
Employee Burden Rate
0%
Extra cost above salary
Annual Difference
$0
Cost advantage
Beyond the Numbers — Key Considerations
🔒Control over work/hours/methods✅ Employee (full control)
⚡Flexibility to scale up/down✅ Contractor (easier to end)
🧠Institutional knowledge / loyalty✅ Employee (long-term)
⚖️Legal / misclassification risk⚠️ High risk if misclassified
🌍Access to specialized skills✅ Contractor (global talent)
Hire and pay either — in one platform
Gusto handles W-2 employees and 1099 contractors in one place. Automated tax filing, onboarding, and compliance.
⚠ Sponsored links. We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the IRS tests for employee vs contractor? ▾
The IRS uses a multi-factor test — the key question is behavioral and financial control. If you control how and when the work is done, provide tools/equipment, the worker works exclusively for you, and the relationship is permanent — that looks like an employee even if you call them a contractor. Misclassifying an employee as a contractor can result in back taxes, penalties, and interest of 3-5 years of payroll taxes. When in doubt, consult a CPA.
Why do contractors cost more per hour but less overall? ▾
Contractors cost more per hour because they cover their own benefits, SE taxes, equipment, and vacation time in their rate. But they often cost less annually because: you only pay for hours worked (no PTO, holidays, sick days), no benefits cost, no payroll taxes, no unemployment insurance, and you can scale hours up or down. For project-based or variable-hour needs, contractors often win financially despite higher rates.
Can I convert a contractor to an employee? ▾
Yes — many businesses start with contractors and convert to employees as the role becomes permanent and full-time. The conversion process involves withholding payroll taxes from their first paycheck, setting up benefits, and filing the appropriate employer tax accounts. You should issue a W-2 at year-end instead of 1099. Give the person advance notice and document the change clearly. Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll both handle this transition easily.